I read all the reviews and asked in different social groups before purchasing this coat. I debated about the light version vs the regular and so far, I am happy I got the regular tundra. I live in MD and our weather is very unpredictable and I've actually had to wear it a couple of times this fall. I sized up in this coat. I typically purchase XL in BP, however, I was nervous about room in my shoulders and I am glad I sized up. So, it fits my shoulders, it's a little long in the sleeves, and there is a good amount of room in the body of the coat, however, if I would have gotten a XL, the shoulders would have been tight and it would be too short when I lift my arms. I am 5'4" and around 200# and normally purchase XL in BP in sports bras (36/38 D/DD) and XL in leggings. I am hoping it holds up for a while and I can get through a few winters in it.